In our very first post about our electric smoker, 10 Foods to Smoke in Your Electric Smoker, I mentioned pork butt, which is sometimes called pork shoulder. The thing is, most people smoke a pork butt to make pulled pork, but in doing that, you are so missing out on something WAY better: Smoked Pork Butt for slicing. It’s smokey, juicy and A-MAZ-ING.
Note: This post contains affiliate links. When you click the link and make a purchase through the link, we make a little money, this helps to keep The Semiconservative Granola Girl going. Thank you for your support.
Smoked Pork Butt for Slicing
It turns out, that my family is not actually a fan of pulled pork. I used to make it a couple times a summer in our crockpot before we got our electric smoker, but now, my husband confesses that he actually isn’t a big fan. I mean he’ll eat it, but if we are going to take the time to smoke a pork butt, we are not going to smother it in barbecue sauce. And, truth be told, it’s way easier to smoke a pork butt for slicing because it is fewer steps.
Preparing the Meat
You do have to plan ahead because it is better if the infusion step has time to soak in overnight, but 4 or 5 hours will do the trick. And you will need a special tool to do this step: an injector. But the key is apple juice or cider or apple juice concentrate.
Use the injector to add apple juice directly to the meat. Poke holes throughout and on all sides, adding juice until it “leaks.” Then set the meat aside for at least four hours, but overnight is better.
Half an hour to an hour before you are ready to smoke, bring your meat to room temp and coat it with yellow mustard, then liberally apply your favorite dry rub. We like to make our own. Check out our recipe for a mild rub Semiconservative Granola Girl Dry Rub.
Prime the Smoker
While your meat is coming to room temperature. You can get your smoker ready. Preheat to 225°F. Load your wood tray according to manufacture’s directions and allow your smoker to fill with smoke. We like to use hickory because it gives the deepest smoke flavor, but you could use apple to stick with a theme.
Add the meat, smoking to an internal temperature of 165°F. Wrap in foil and let your meat rest for 20-30 minutes. Or (as happens to us often!), if you are not quite ready to eat, you can let it rest longer, just wrap it in foil, then in a towel, then you can put it in a cooler and use the cooler the opposite way you use it to keep something cold (that means no ice!).
Smoked Pork Butt
When you are ready to eat, just slice it up and serve. You could add a barbecue sauce, we like to eat it just the way it came out of the smoker: juicy and smokey and delicious. With all that apple, it seems so autumnal. Perfect to eat with homemade applesauce (my son’s kitchen specialty) and roasted butternut squash. (Leftover butternut squash? Tomorrow’s breakfast: Butternut Squash Prosciutto Hash. Left over pork? Reimagine that leftover as Smoked Pork Fried Rice–recipe coming soon.)
If you are looking for other great electric smoker recipes, be sure to check out my Electric Smoker Page with an index to all of our electric smoker tips, tricks and recipes.